Sign in  |  Register  |  Help

Most Read on APEsphere

Most Commented on APEsphere

Blogs we like

Resources



Google to China: we don't do complicity in evil, either

Add this link to:

Related Links

Report Abuse:

So that we can keep the site friendly, legal and on-topic, please click the Report Abuse button if this story breaks the APEsphere Code.

Posted by apesphere on 13 Jan 2010

Image courtesy Robert Scoble via Flickr

In a timely follow up to my post yesterday on whether companies need a foreign policy, Google has effectively delivered an ultimatum to China.


The ultimatum essentially says "let us provide uncensored Google in China or we will shut Google.cn". Naturally, no one expects China to accede to Google's wishes.


The background an a good analysis are provided by Imagethief here.


Imagethief does not mention the meeting between Internet business leaders and Hillary Clinton last week, and I cannot help but feel that the timing of this announcement is linked to that meeting even if there are broader events leading up to this. Eric Schmidt is simply too close to the Obama administration to do this on the fly. Certainly to China it will look like it is, and if there is one thing that was acknowledged in that meeting it is that any stand US companies take in relation to human rights in China will be viewed by China as a proxy move by the US.


While Imagethief notes and the Wall Street Journal implies that Google's eventual withdrawal from China on human rights grounds makes it really difficult for Microsoft to remain, I would be very surprised if Microsoft, the State Department and others did not already know of the move before Google dropped today's bombshell.


 

ADVERTISMENT

Comments

Add a comment

Already an APEsphere user? Login for one-click commenting. If not, sign in by email.
 
 
KenAPierce
on 13 Jan 2010
Knowledge is power, and the free dissemination of information threatens any overweening government. So, you are correct, China will not comply, showing once again that they are not a liberalizing state (except by comparison to the Cultural Revolution, maybe), but a repressive regime cynically looking to exploit the fruit of capitalism for their own unjust ends (the way Eastern Block countries used to sell the release of political and religious prisoners to get some solid currency).So, bravo Google, for finally standing up. The blood of Chinese dissidents thanks you.